Amica Mutual vs Shelter Insurance - Compare Car Insurance Rates and Reviews

Both Amica Mutual and Shelter Insurance offer car insurance coverage, but does their pricing and service measure up to your standards? With all the flashy advertising done by insurance companies, it's easy to overlook the real experiences of consumers with these companies.

Quickly compare rates from top auto insurance companies like Amica Mutual and Shelter Insurance to find the cheapest rate!

Compare Rates

To easily compare rates of car insurance companies in your area, simply click on the above quote button and submit the short form.

Comparing Amica Mutual to Shelter Insurance

  Amica Mutual Ratings Shelter Insurance Ratings
Policy Offerings Amica Mutual Policy Offerings Shelter Insurance Policy Offerings
Pricing Amica Mutual Pricing Shelter Insurance Pricing
Billing and Payment Amica Mutual Billing Shelter Insurance Billing
Contacting the Insurer Amica Mutual Support Shelter Insurance Support
Overall Satisfaction Amica Mutual Satisfaction Shelter Insurance Satisfaction
Compare Rates Now Click to Get Your Free Price Comparison

Data source: J.D.Power 2011 National Auto Insurance Study

Amica Mutual scored higher Shelter Insurance on policy offerings. That rating factors in the types of coverages offered and additional endorsements and features that can be added to your insurance policy. Having better policy offerings can mean less cost for more coverage.

Amica Mutual and Shelter Insurance Price Comparison

Amica Mutual scored better than Shelter Insurance on consumer price ratings. This doesn't mean that Amica Mutual will always have better pricing on car insurance than Shelter Insurance. Amica Mutual or Shelter Insurance may have the lowest rate for your personal situation, but you have to get quotes from both companies to find out.

Amica Mutual vs Shelter Insurance - Compare Car Insurance Rates and Reviews

Since different companies rate drivers in different ways, you need to get a car insurance comparison quote now to find out which company offers the lowest rates in your area. It may be Amica Mutual or Shelter Insurance, or possibly even a different company.

Consumers rated Amica Mutual higher than Shelter Insurance when it comes to having more flexible billing and payment options.

Knowing you'll be able to get in touch with your company in case of an accident or claim may give you good peace of mind. Survey results show that Amica Mutual came in higher than Shelter Insurance when ranking consumers ability to get in touch with the company.

How to Choose the Best Company

Does a higher overall rating really mean a company is better? Consumer ratings are a good place to start when buying car insurance, but just because Amica Mutual earned a better consumer rating as Shelter Insurance, that doesn't mean you will have the identical experience.

Best Way to Compare Auto Insurance Rates

  • Higher physical damage deductibles mean less premium paid
  • If you have an independent insurance agent, have them compare rates with multiple companies
  • Better credit means lower car insurance rates
  • Better drivers pay lower car insurance premiums