Allstate vs Amica Mutual - Compare Car Insurance Rates and Reviews

Car insurance from Allstate or Amica Mutual may be cheap in your area, but it's important to find out if the company's service is as good as their prices. Finding out how other insureds have fared with car insurance companies is a good indication of how your experience will be with the same company.

Quickly compare rates from top auto insurance companies like Allstate and Amica Mutual to find the cheapest rate!

Compare Rates

Most consumers like saving time AND money, and you can do that simply by clicking the button above and getting a quick free car insurance quote.

Allstate and Amica Mutual Consumer Ratings

  Allstate Ratings Amica Mutual Ratings
Policy Offerings Allstate Policy Offerings Amica Mutual Policy Offerings
Pricing Allstate Pricing Amica Mutual Pricing
Billing and Payment Allstate Billing Amica Mutual Billing
Contacting the Insurer Allstate Support Amica Mutual Support
Overall Satisfaction Allstate Satisfaction Amica Mutual Satisfaction
Compare Rates Now Click to Get Your Free Price Comparison

Data source: J.D.Power 2011 National Auto Insurance Study

Allstate scored lower Amica Mutual on policy offerings, which means that Amica Mutual offers more coverages or policy types than Allstate. The ability to add more coverages to your policies makes it easier to custom-tailor an insurance program that meets your needs.

Allstate and Amica Mutual Price Comparison

Allstate received a lower rating than Amica Mutual on pricing comparison. Will Allstate always have worse car insurance prices than Amica Mutual? Not necessarily. It's important that you compare car insurance rates of both Allstate and Amica Mutual and not just assume one will be better.

Allstate vs Amica Mutual - Compare Car Insurance Rates and Reviews

Better drivers pay lower car insurance rates, and Allstate and Amica Mutual may give steeper discounts to good drivers. Getting a car insurance comparison quote is the only way to know for sure which company gives the lowest rates to good drivers.

Policyholders felt that Allstate was worse than Amica Mutual when it came to payment and billing.

Getting in contact with your car insurance company may be the most important rating to pay attention to. For ease of contacting the insurance company, Allstate ended up worse than Amica Mutual.

So Which Company is Better?

Does more stars actually translate into a better consumer insurance buying experience? The overall satisfaction rating of Allstate shows fewer stars than Amica Mutual, but different consumers have different experiences with the same company.

Keys to Finding the Best Car Insurance

  • Not filing small claims can earn you a claim-free discount on your car insurance
  • Make sure you compare apples-to-apples coverages
  • Better drivers pay lower car insurance premiums
  • If you have an independent insurance agent, have them compare rates with multiple companies